We get this call every winter. A Balmain cottage, painted three years ago, peeling in sheets along the bottom of the side wall. The owner's angry with the last painter. Fair enough, except the paint was fine. Underneath it was hard cement render, and under that a solid brick wall that had breathed since 1885 and suddenly couldn't.
Old homes need to breathe. That's plain physics, and ignoring it costs Sydney homeowners more than any other mistake we see on older houses.
How an old solid wall handles water
A Victorian terrace wall is solid brick, two or three bricks thick, 230 to 350mm. It's laid in lime mortar and finished in lime render outside and lime plaster inside. No cavity. No membrane.
Rain soaks in a little. Ground moisture creeps up a little. Then it all dries back out through both faces of the wall on the next dry, windy day. The wall gets wet and dries, wet and dries, for a hundred-odd years, and it's fine.
Lime is what makes that work. Lime mortar and lime render are soft and full of connected pores, so water vapour moves through them easily. They're also weaker than the brick, on purpose. When the wall moves, the mortar takes the cracking, and mortar is cheap to repoint. Bricks aren't.
Lime vs cement: the actual difference
- Strength: Portland cement mortar is several times harder than lime mortar, and harder than plenty of soft old Sydney bricks
- Permeability: cement render lets far less vapour through than lime. Put an acrylic paint on top and less again
- Flexibility: lime tolerates movement, and fine cracks heal slowly as it keeps carbonating. Cement cracks, and the cracks let water in that can't get back out
- Reversibility: lime comes off without hurting the brick. Cement takes the brick face with it
When the mortar is harder than the brick, the brick fails first. You'll see it on walls repointed in cement in the 1970s. The mortar joints stand proud and the brick faces between them have eroded back 5 or 10mm. The wall is giving up its expensive part to save its cheap one.
What happens when you seal an old wall
Coat the outside of a solid wall in cement render and a sealing paint and the water still gets in. Up from the ground, through hairline cracks, from a leaking gutter. It just can't leave through the face any more.
So it moves sideways and upward until it finds a way out. The inside face of the wall. The top edge of the sealed area. The junction with the skirting. It carries salts with it, and wherever it finally evaporates, the salts crystallise and push off whatever's there.
That's the band of blown plaster in the hallway. The paint bubbling 1.2 metres up. The render that sounds hollow when you knock on it. The full mechanism is in our post on rising damp in old Sydney homes.
Breathable paint for old homes
Paint is the last layer, and it can undo everything underneath it. Here's what goes on an old masonry wall, from most breathable to least.
- Limewash: lime putty, water and pigment. The most breathable finish there is. It chalks, it needs redoing every few years, and it only goes on lime or bare masonry. On the right wall it looks beautiful
- Mineral silicate paint: a potassium silicate binder that bonds chemically into a mineral surface. Very breathable, very durable, and it holds colour under Sydney UV. It won't stick to old acrylic, so it needs bare render or a compatible primer
- Breathable acrylics and heritage-grade paints: made with much higher vapour permeability than standard exterior acrylic. A fair compromise on a wall with a history of acrylic coats that can't all come off
- Standard exterior acrylic: right for timber, cavity brick and modern render. Wrong on a damp solid wall
When cement is the right call
Plenty of Sydney houses don't have solid walls. A lot of Federation houses were built with a cavity, and a cavity wall manages moisture in a completely different way. Weatherboard houses breathe through their joints and their subfloor. A 1960s extension in cement render is a cement-render building and wants cement-compatible materials.
So the rule is to match the material to the wall. Before we specify anything, we work out what the wall is. Check the wall thickness at a doorway. Look at the mortar. Pull a subfloor vent and look inside.
Fixing a wall that's already been sealed
Undoing it is real work. The cement render comes off in small sections, carefully, because it's bonded hard and will take brick face with it if you rush. Cement joints get raked out and repointed in lime. The wall gets time to dry.
Then lime render goes back in three coats: a scratch coat, a floating coat and a finish coat, each left 3 to 7 days to firm up before the next. Lime cures by absorbing carbon dioxide, and it needs moisture while it does. In a Sydney summer that means misting the wall and shading it from direct sun. Rush lime and it cracks.
Then a breathable paint. Then the wall gets on with being a wall for another few decades.
What this means for your house
- Lime mortar and lime render on solid masonry, matched in strength to the brick
- A breathable paint system on any wall that needs to dry out
- Treat the cause of damp first, and paint last
- Leave face brick unpainted
- Find out what your walls are made of before anyone quotes you a product
Matching materials to the age of the wall is half of our remedial repairs, and it decides what goes on in our heritage painting. Book a free on-site quote and we'll tell you what your walls are made of and what they need.